Home assistant zigbee2mqtt vs zha. Because i cant get this button to work on Deconz thanks.


  1. Home
    1. Home assistant zigbee2mqtt vs zha You also have Zigbee2MQTT available. 168. Before trying HA, I used zigbee2mqtt and nodered to pick up zigbee devices. I have used both and now use zigbee2mqtt. On the other hand, going from ZHA → Zi I’m curious if anyone jumped from deconz with the Conbee II over to zigbee2mqtt with the Conbee II. To pair it, remove the battery cover and hold the button for a couple of seconds until the LED starts I’m looking for zigbee coordinator that is accessible using ehternet and would work with both zha and zigbee@mqtt (not at the same time, but want to have option to switch). Current Gateways: Hue, Conbee II, Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. “Compliant” means: No bugs No extra features not in the specification (manufacturers are allowed to add these) Instead you have to look for a list of Yet another migration-thread i know. 1 / Frontend 20240906. kkqd1337 (Kkqd1337 TLDR Both can be used for ZHA, E is never and there pairing issues reported, not so much for P but E is the same chip as Home Assistant is using natively in the yellow and the new skynet connect dongle Z2MQTT only option is P for stability, E is experimental But use the search for more detailed info, I have both dongles but havent tested the E (dreading the . I would like ZHA to be successful, but in a way that allowed it to continue to run (and control lights for the significant other ) even during Home Assistant upgrades, crashes Zigbee Home Automation The ZHA (Zigbee Home Automation) integration Integrations connect and integrate Home Assistant with your devices, services, and more. I got a extra Sonoff 3. Whereas Z2M seems to run independent of HA. It differs from others with: ZHA and Zigbee2MQTT variants Uses a timer helper to trigger next start (when external sensor does not update for a long time) Does not use a delay/restart, as it can cause situation when attribute is I got a spare USB dongle, so I got both ZHA and Zigbee2MQTT running in parallel, and I switched every device one by one. All three options support majority of devices. So I’m tempted testing the other Zigbee integration. the Paulmann Gent remote). I have migrated most of my automations and scenes (as scripts) and really enjoying the added features and control I can have now. Configuration. deconz is great and really stable for me, don’t get me wrong, but zigbee2mqtt seems to have a much wider array of devices, especially for US users, whereas “most things” work with deconz with the attitude of “give it a try, it should, but if not request a new device be Hello everyone, I am looking to move into home automation using home assistant, I have purchased two tuya zigbee devices (door sensor and presence sensor). Before this, it was Hi all, I want to expand my HA system with Zigbee devices. ZHA was in an early state, can communicate directly with the coordinator hardware (or - to my knowledge - via deCONZ REST API, too), but failed to pair some Innr bulbs. Now I want to get some devices with the Enocean protocol and need some help at the beginning. . I’ve seen mixed reviews on the Sonoff WiFi bridges, but have no first hand It does include a network map and Home Assistant as a general interface but just for managing your Zigbee devices I actually prefer the UI of Zigbee2MQTT assistant. 🚀 Updates will be published on the project’s GitHub repository. ZHA works just like that and is plenty. 40. When I migrated from ZHA to zigbee2mqtt, I had ~60 For ZHA, both the P and E work well. It worked! BUT, I couldn’t get my Xiaomi PIR sensor to pair with ZHA. HAOS is running in a virtual machine on VirtualBox. The sensors read as normal when close to the coordinator. I’ve heard of a lot of success with zigbee2mqtt in binding and other areas and have considered migrating over and # Zigbee2MQTT vs ZHA vs deCONZ - WATCH THIS BEFORE YOU DECIDE! Seems on Con for ZHA is that if HA goes down, so do all the Zigbee devices. Currently, all devices are connected to SkyConnect (on a well-shielded USB cable far My plan that I use the SkyConnect for ZHA and the eWelink for Zigbee2MQTT. This user has been inactive for some time, the blueprint below is still available, but please be advised it may no longer work. In that thread, there are reports of better Schnall dich an, denn wir tauchen tief ein in die Welt von ZHA und Zigbee2Mqtt! Hier noch eine kurze Anmerkung: Ich empfehle niemanden der mit ZHA simon42 Community ZHA vs. 4 Supervisor 2023. I’ve since read that ZHA doesn’t play nicely with these Ikea switches and instead to use Zigbee2MQTT addon. A plug may work fine in ZHA for example, but power monitoring may only be available in Z2M. So is it better to use zigbee2mqtt or the built in ZHA integration? bernhard November 2, 2020, 3:10pm 2. This has great benefits in my setup since I use many GU10’s grouped up as pairs. 3 or higher) Option 2: Direct Link Co</details> Home Assistant Community 🎮 ZHA, deCONZ, Zigbee2MQTT - Ikea E1743 On/Off Switch & Dimmer Universal blueprint - all actions + double click events - control lights, media players Hi. 0 firmware of my Sonoff Zigbee Dongle E I always have this in the z2mqtt log : zh:ezsp: Deprecated driver ‘ezsp’ currently in use, ‘ember’ will become the officially supported EmberZNet Hi everyone, I was originally trying to use Zigbee2MQTT, but noticed it would crash the whole of HAOS when the process is stopped. Perfect to run on a Raspberry Pi or a local server. What is best is what works fro you. ZHA is not bad, but Z2M is a godsend. I believe ZHA and zigbee2mqtt don’t support that. I’m currently running zigbee devices trough tuya wifi gateway and then tuya cloud, but it is kinda slow, especially since some of the switches wait for double click etc. Now I am looking to integrate them with Homeassistant (installed on my RasperryPi 4B). My take on it is here: ZHA Vs Zigbee2Mqtt - #3 by jerrm. ⬇ Get Started Option 1: My Home Assistant Click the badge to import this Blueprint (needs Home Assistant Core 2021. Perhaps ZigBee2MQTT? Or any other suggestions. All three have good development and get new devices added. Nice thing is you can run both ZHA and ZigBee2MQTT together and take your time in the move. Hello, Following the upgrade to 7. 01. which differ from the ZHA event names if I listen to events. It works quite well for me, except when it comes to exposing the battery level of certain devices like the IKEA sensors that use CR2032 batteries. They have several communications protocols to choose from and - at least by the ordering - it’s an either/or at the time of ordering. I tried ZHA first, deCONZ seconds and Zigbee2MQTT last. Obviously both use the same Hi everyone, I want to connect a Zigbee LAN coordinator to Home Assistant OS (ZHA or Z2M) using a Wireguard VPN Add-on. Actually it's the same with zigbee2mqtt because MQTT plugin has autodiscovery functionality and zigbee2mqtt uses it to automatically add/remove/update devices from HA. So I decided to try and switch to ZHA. Cross-applications migration only saves you the trouble of having to manually re-pair all devices, though note that you will still probably have to re ZHA vs. The tight coupling of ZHA and Home Assistant should be I have home assistant on a RPi4. I know Also make sure that you do not have enabled permit_join: true in your configuration. Home Assistant Zigbee2MQTT Weridness i see explanations of how to make it work with ZHA, but I cant seem to get that installed. And I would like to # Zigbee2MQTT vs ZHA vs deCONZ - WATCH THIS BEFORE YOU DECIDE! Seems on Con for ZHA is that if HA goes down, so do all the Zigbee devices. If you are not using Home Assistant or if you need to run the smart home controller and the Zigbee control software separately, the choice is It supports more devices, gives you more control, let's you put your coordinator wherever you want (not just where HA is), and gives you more independence from HA, if you ever need it. All three work well when setup. 9 release it is possible to backup the state/configuration of a Zigbee coordinator using ZHA. zigbee2mqtt, zha, zigbee. 0 USB Dongle Plus V2” (model “ZBDongle-E”) , Aeotec Zi-Stick (model “ZGA008”), as well as in the easyiot ZB-GW04 This is my take on the automation to send external temperature to Danfoss Ally TRV. Have not looked further into this. After using ZHA and zigbee2mqtt I prefer zigbee2mqtt dashboard over ZHA configuration. I While ZHA device support keeps getting better, Z2M still has better device support, and for devices, more full featured support. Having come from a dev background, the learning curve is not too steep (although yaml) I end up getting a Sonoff zigbee 3 usb dongle to act as my zigbee coordinator, and it works really well. been using Deconz lately and found that even devices that don’t show in PhosCon are often recognised as entities in Hi started getting into Home Assistant over Christmas last year. If I just get the Xiaomi hub, is there an easy way to Being able to run both ZHA and zigbee2mqtt will be nice since that should prevent me from having to migrate all of the bulbs. What are the differences and pros ans cons of using ZHA over the deconz add-on? Should I consider switching? I assume that I cannot, or Apparently it is, as it is rebranded Linptech Zigbee version. Sending a command to each light individually (especially with transition effect or changing brightness) doesn’t change all lights smoothly because of all the requests. 1 / Supervisor 2024. It’s all configured with ZHA. There a couple ways to use zigbee2mqtt with Home Assistant. The plugs state can be controlled via zigbee2mqtt. Home Assistant Community ITead’s “Sonoff Zigbee 3. Home Assistant Community 🎮 ZHA, deCONZ, Zigbee2MQTT - IKEA E2001/E2002 Hey Everyone, Just a quick non-sponsored post/feedback about the SmartWings blinds/cover/shades I just receive a blind for our new house (we only ordered 1 as a sample before getting more), my first thoughts: My wife gave it a big thumbs up in terms of design I quickly configured it in Zigbee2MQTT and it was adopted easily and fully working without any When I moved between deCONZ, ZHA, and zigbee2mqtt, that required everything to re-pair with reset entity IDs, but not having to redo group automations was a big time savings. This morning I’ve deleted ZHA and installed Z2MQTT. Connected to my Zigbee2mqtt network are mainly xiaomi devices (motion sensors, contact sensors) and Ikea devices (power outlets) I also have a phillips hue with 10 Phillips hue lights and 4 Innr lights. com) Zigbee 簡介 在台灣玩 Home Assistant 的族群裡，除了 WiFi 裝置外，最常會用到的就是 Zigbee 裝置了。由於 Zigbee 低耗電的特性，使得不少的 Zigbee 裝置可透過電池供電，在不方便配實體線路的地方會是很好的方案。 不過不像 WiFi 大多數的裝置都有內建支援，絕大多數的硬體環境是沒有內建 Zigbee 通訊晶片的 If you only plan to use this (or Home Assistant event entities) and want to disable the Via Home Assistant sensor entity integration below, set homeassistant: {legacy_triggers: false} (see Configuration for more info). What I’m worried about is the “HUB Software”. Sonoff WiFi Bridges. It has been a really good experience: quite stable with few problems, mixing devices from multiple manufa Converting between ZHA (built-in Zigbee Home Assistant) and Zigbee2MQTT Do the radio migration in ZHA or go fresh with the ZMQTT route? I’m reading If you’re new to Zigbee and/or Home Assistant, my recommendation is to use In this comparison, we delve into two prominent open-source Zigbee gateways, specifically from a Home Assistant user's perspective: Zigbee2MQTT and ZHA (Zigbee Home Automation). ZHA, Zigbee2MQTT and Phoscon all serve the same purpose - to provide the DS220+ “saw” my Sonoff as did HA, and ZHA would auto install and detect it, but it would not configure, untill I took it off a passive hub and plugged it in direct. The home assistant zigb Hi, I’m currently using HomeAssistant Blue with a ConBee2 dongle for Zigbee access. 0 firmware of my Sonoff Zigbee Dongle E I always have this in the z2mqtt log : zh:ezsp: Deprecated driver ‘ezsp’ currently in use, ‘ember’ will become the officially supported EmberZNet driver in next release. 0). 4. However, it is not working yet neither with ZHA nor Zigbee2MQTT. I’ve been digging around here as of late and seeing all kinds of great ZHA-based Blueprints popping up and can’t help myself but wonder if I’m putting too much work into Deconz when the future seems to be moving over to ZHA with my ConBee II stick. I’m looking at buying a refurb dell mini pc 16g ram and 250gb ssd to start and want to start with zigbee but I’m not sure if it’s zigbee or zigbee2mqtt I’m best Hi so I’m preparing a blueprint for my smart home and I need some help understanding & deciding which hub & interface I should use. Nevertheless, commands are often not arriving. Home Assistant Integration. These are my first attempts at creating a blueprint. My configuration is; Sonoff dongle plus 88 zigbee devices - mix of everything I could get my hands Don’t forget that the first post in a community guide is a wiki - feel free to add to it or correct it. The process was as follows: For every integration or add-on, I had to start with a fresh Home Assistant installation and then I installed the integration or add-on so ZHA vs Z2M. The switch was detected with ZHA without issues. Switching from one gateway solution to another can be a bit of a pain, depending on the number of ZHA is a proprietary home assistant component, you cannot use it outside of the ecosystem. Suppose I have such a device, is there any chance that I could get it working with ZHA, by creating a ZHA quirk myself? Could I use Zigbee2MQTT code as inspiration for that? Has someone done that before? I’ve recently started on the whole HA journey. I’ve narrowed my search down to the three devices in the title. deCONZ also failed to control the entire set of device brands I own (IKEA, Innr, OSRAM/LEDVance, Philips/Signify). There are people working on it to make it compatable with Z2M. 10. Today I discovered that there is also a Zigbee Home Automation (ZHA) integration available. Deconz on the other hand, ZHA vs Zigbee2MQTT vs deCONZ Conbee II ready to go on latest firmware. Zigbee has been a bit of a mixed bag for me, and then particularly with my Aqara The best Zigbee Coordinator hardware radio adapter to buy in December 2023 Zigbee Coordinator product purchase recommendation summary: If you today want a Zigbee Coordinator that can work great with either Home Assistant’s ZHA integration (built-in Zigbee gateway implementation) or Zigbee2MQTT (third-party Zigbee gateway application that can From my experience using both Zigbee2MQTT and ZHA, as well as too many other zigbee systems, the best setup to work with Home Assistant is to run Zigbee2MQTT in a separate docker container from Home Assistant, as well as a MQTT broker in a docker container separate from Home Assistant. I’ve already Hello - I would really appreciate any guidance on this issue. The sensor “Opening” seems not to work – I get “closed” here even when the physical switch is toggled on. If a device doesn’t work with ZHA and that is critical to your network, try Zigbee2MQTT or vice versa. Both are Sonoff ZB Dongle Plus E. Powered by a worldwide community of tinkerers and DIY enthusiasts. deConz seems to have issues with groups, ZHA is not really mature. I prefer ZigBee2mqtt because I'm not tied up to home assistant. 04. I don’t want to convert my existing Zigbee network from ZHA to Zigbee2MQTT as the thought of re-pairing all my devices and adjusting automations I am having random problems with this setup RaspBerry Pi 5 (8GB) ConBee III Home Assistant OS ( Core 2024. This thread is archived Running Home Assistant official Docker image on a NUC with Ubuntu 18. Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. I am trying to set up with Conbee / ZHA, no luck so far. Via Home Assistant event entity (experimental). I have a separate MQTT instance running outside HA and I run many types of IKEA RODRET & SOMRIG - Control anything (ZHA/Z2M) Hello people. I have two Zigbee adaptors, one being used on the ZHA network and one just plugged in. The Hi, i am using deconz for now, it works wit events ID but seems now the ZHA component is native supported it seems? (according on the github site ) any1 tried it yet? do we still need to work with automations and event id’s? for example an ikea remote switch? or how will those button pressed be handled in HA? since it has about 10 buttons on it second question : If you bought a Zigbee coordinator stick, you can choose between different integrations or add-ons to control your Zigbee devices in Home Assistant. g. I searched for Zigbee co-ordinators and found these two, Zigstar uzg and SMLIGHT SLZB-06M. it takes half a second. Have not I could use some assistance with Zigbee groups & clusters (using ZHA and an EZSP). When I stop ZHA, it also crashes the whole OS. So now I have 2 zigbee networks 1 zigbee2mqtt and 1 Phillips hue. @jerrm Seems a bit pedantic to argue where ZHA or Zigbee2mqtt supports a device, in some definition of ‘core’ system or via some type of add on driver subsystem. 0 USB Dongle Plus V2” (model "ZBDongle-E") based on Silicon Labs EFR32MG21 radio SoC/MCU In future i want to buy few of this sensors so want to connect to my home If you want more info and see what the differences are between those three solutions, see -> deCONZ vs ZHA vs zigbee2mqtt - Configuration / Zigbee - Home Assistant Community (home-assistant. Zigbee2mqtt should support all the features while ZHA is missing some features from these devices. 0 - latest Background Until recently Philips Hue devices have been controlled locally Hello - Looking to purchase some Smartwings roller shades (I think). ZHA vs Zigbee2MQTT upvotes If you’re a Home Assistant user who is getting started with Zigbee devices, then you may be tempted to just use Zigbee Home Automation (ZHA), Home Assistant’s built-in Zigbee implementation. Home Assistant Zigbee2MQTT. I created a Zigbee group and added all of the ZHA (Zigbee Home Automation) Zigbee2MQTT; Deconz; ZHA and ZigBee2MQTT are compatible with a bunch of zigbee coordinators, including the top three currently on the market we listed above. Okee two questions, i am running HASS with a Conbee II stick and i use ZHA. Now here it gets interesting: I was originally on Z2M, my server crashed deCONZ vs ZHA vs zigbee2mqtt. maxym November 16, 2020, 5:10pm 123. I run HA in RPi3 with a deCONZ Conbee II zigbee dongle and with deCONZ add-on running the Phoscon s/w which works fine. Most of the time, the battery level always shows 100% even after several months, or it gets stuck at a fixed percentage (e. Anyone having issues or opinions about which Zigbee home assistant integration to use with the blue series switches? I’ve seen mixed things on the forums, some seem to have better UI experiences with ZHA whereas some people seemed to have issues getting things set up with Z2M. With the 2022. The Silicon Labs EFR32MG21 based Zigbee SiP radio module it uses is the exact same “SM-011 V1. I actually like the overview and interface of Zigbee2Mqtt in the FYI, SMLIGHT released SMLIGHT SLZB-07 Zigbee Coordinator USB radio adapter based on the same popular Silicon Labs EFR32MG21 radio SoC/MCU that is also used in the Home Assistant SkyConnect (USB stick), ITead’s “Sonoff Zigbee 3. 1/24 network, and the Wireguard Add-on is on the Advantages? Comparisons of supported devices, capacity, range? Mainly planning to use Xiaomi Aqara devices for now, heard they did not always play nicely with ZHA. Follow this link for more Hello, Who is running ZHA and Z2M on the same LAN coordinator ? I’d be very interested to read your feedback. I am using both Zigbee and Matter via the that dongle. The host is running Ubuntu 24. I have around 200 Zigbee devices (most Philips Hue bulbs) on a single floor. EDIT: Found related issue on zha-device-handlers [Device Support Request] Aqara H1 wireless switch double rocker (model WRS-R02) · Issue #940 · zigpy/zha-device-handlers · GitHub. ZHA has it's own devices section where you can list and analyze ZHA devices. All my devices are connected via ZHA, as that seemed the way to go. I recently got a handful of Sengled floodlight bulbs, and got a GE/Jasco Enbrighten dimmer switch (43080) to use for physical control via Zigbee groups. The plugs appear on the zigbee2mqtt map but only as linked routes to themselves and back to the coordinator. I have never tried the HA official integration, so I cannot speak to that. Mainly this is related to the support of different devices of course, since I figured that my smoke detectors and radiator valves, e. This method work by responding to the state Hello, from what I read on this thread, Sonoff Zbbridge appears to be unstable with ZHA and Zigbee2mqtt. If ‘quirks’ or ‘herdsman converters’ were not necessary then why are they there? I’m far from an expert on the zigbee standards, however it appears to be that it was Hello! I am trying to get Zigbee2MQTT working and struggling a bit. 8. The problem is that the zigbee stick is also addressed to by HA, which conflicts with Zigbee2MQTT and crashes it. So I would buy a P in case I ever need to switch between ZHA and Zigbee2MQTT. And, actually I was able to configure Aqara TVOC without issues. Someone is telling me Zigbee2MQTT is better. Q: Does having Deconz installed block ZHA install? Because i cant get this button to work on Deconz thanks. To clarify; this new backup feature in Home Assistant’s ZHA integration will obviously never be specifically made to be a “ZHA to Zigbee2MQTT migration tool” nor a “Zigbee2MQTT or ZHA migration tool”. Check the li I’ve always had a nagging concern that my Zigbee coordinator could die and I’ll have to repair all my devices. I’m dabbling with z2m to see if it is any more stable (Would need to reset ZHA every couple of days as would cut out) My question is this, Can z2m be exposed to the Alexa app via The reason to add the zigbee2mqtt network is that it will allow me to incorporate or add devices that are not in zha or that have more parameters and control on zigbee2mqtt. Zigbee. The problems are when want to migrate from ZHA to Zigbee2MQTT, or from Zigbee2MQTT to ZHA. 4). Caring about reporting frequency is I got a spare USB dongle, so I got both ZHA and Zigbee2MQTT running in parallel, and I switched every device one by one. My Zigbee network has been precarious since the recent HA updates. I've tried ZHA, Zigbee2MQTT and deCONZ and personally would recommend deCONZ. However, this still shows the same behaviour. I’ve recently started looking into Zigbee devices. Sonoff ZBDongle-P Apparently it is, as it is rebranded Linptech Zigbee version. And it doesn’t seem limited to Sonoff (which is not surprising, as the same chipset and identical firmware are common). Howdy! I’ve been thinking about this post for ages now. 1 Everyone has their preferences. Home Assistant Community ZHA, DeConz/Phoscon or Both? Third party integrations. After 18 wipes and rebuilds going to try something else, ZHA. NathanCu (Nathan Curtis) November 28, 2024, 1:23pm 21. I use ZHA for most of my devises. henry8866: I’m sorry for the poor experience you had, but saying integrations are the weak part of Home Assistant is just not true, sound like you don’t understand what integrations are, because otherwise you would not say that z2m is As discussed here: Sonoff Zigbee USB Dongle not working with IKEA Tradfri buttons, lots of people are have trouble with Ikea shortcut buttons (in particular — but possibly other Ikea remotes as well). 3 is out. I intend to use Zigbee2MQTT, but only because from what I’ve read it’s a little bit more customizable compared to ZHA. As mentioned, Zigbee2MQTT and ZHA has normally no control of your Zigbee network mesh as that is all done onboard the Zigbee Coordinator and handled by its firmware, so scaling on a single Zigbee Coordinator generally has nothing to do with the application level of your Zigbee Gateway host software (unless you enable ”source routing” which is normally not NOTE: I searched through past topics and couldn’t get to a straight answer so starting a new thread especially now that HA Core 2022. Did you start with zigbee2mqtt or migrate from zha to it. 0 /OS 13. Do you have experience of dropping, and re-pair For several frustrating weeks I have been trying to create a reliable Zigbee network. Home Assistant Community ZHA & Zigbee2MQTT together. , 87%) even though The process to compare Zigbee2MQTT vs ZHA vs deCONZ. Maybe you can think that ZHA is best for simple things and zigbee2mqtt is for the “power user”. Hello everybody, I might have just been unable to search properly, but I couldn’t find a topic that answers the following question: what is the difference between HA’s built-in Zigbee support (which I like a lot) and Zigbee2Mqtt. I have a 70+ device network established with ZHA but its limitations are making me want to switch (again) to Zigbee2MQTT (Z2M for brevity). Reply reply With ZHA it’s generic and some things are not ideal. From what I understand, Zigbee2MQTT → ZHA is simple. I currently have about 48 zigbee router devices and 12 end devices that I want to I have installed a Sonoff ZBMINIR2. Set it up, and everything worked perfect, moved some of my devices to make a real life test. Thank you all in advance for your help! I have the Nabu_Casa_SkyConnect_v1. Let’s explore what Z2M is, and why it might be the better choice for your smart home. 09. HA is running in a Raspi 4 with a 4Amp power supply. Check my If you bought a Zigbee coordinator stick, you can choose between different integrations or add-ons to control your Zigbee devices in Home Assistant. Basically, use the one that supports the devices you have. The assistant does feature a better network map than ZHA im my opinion, has nice labels and supports more firmware upgrades. Home Assistant Community ZHA vs Zigbee2MQTT - Pros 'n Cons for conversion. I don’t know about ZHA, but Zigbee2mqtt definitely supports groups. 1 Zigbee2MQTT addon 1. This is fantastic! Is this backup performed as part of a HA backup or does it have to be done manually? If manually, can I automate this? Team, Brought some of these Tuya WiFi Zigbee PIR Motion Sensor When I try to connect to home assistant on my PI I see the logs Received message from unsupported device with Zigbee model 'TS0202' and manufacturer name '_TZ3000_lf56vpxj' TS0202_TZ3000 So my question do I need to flash the firmware here or is there another way? I have only just brought (Phoscon is already using it) Select ‘ignore’ on the ZHA discovery panel (under that arrow): If you want to use ZHA instead, then you need to remove Phoscon. Automations will be in Home Assistant. "Koenkk" of Zigbee2MQTT fame and Omer Kilic a. francisp (Francis) October 23, 2020, 2:34pm 103. io. a. I skipped the installation via the recommended eWeLink App, because I want to use it with Home Assistant. 3 Supervisor 2023. Home Automation----1. However, I could use Home Assistant interfaced to Tasmota WITHOUT ZHA (by using mqtt, instead) as an alternative, but I don’t understand if the same problem happens for Tasmota on Zbbridge too. Snappy and reliable are the goals. allows you to wirelessly connect many off-the-shelf Zigbee-based devices directly to Home Assistant, using one of the many available Zigbee coordinators. I’m thinking of moving it all to Conbee. When the sensors are positioned in their final location, their state does not report. 0. → what device / chipset are your running ?? I’m actually looking for advices from some Zigbee2MQTT expert ! This article shows how to configure Z2M and ZHA to work with a single LAN zigbee adaptor: The author first configure the zigbee network under in Home assistant, you join your devices to the network by pairing with the coordinator, but there is no association at that point between say the button and the bulb. 0” modules and Zigbee firmware by CoolKit-Technologies Hello, Following the upgrade to 7. This guide was written and tested these versions but should also work similarly with later versions: Home Assistant 2023. You will not get a seamless migration as all of the metadata is stored in host application databases. I created a Zigbee group and added all of the Multiple vendor hubs vs zigbee2mqtt (or ZHA) Recently got into HA, moving from a primarily homekit setup. For example I can make my Tasmota or esphome devices listen to ZigBee sensors via mqtt and do automations without the home assistant involved. Sawtaytoes: I’m not sure how large these firmwares are, but I can only do a few a night for the 30 that needed updating. Home Assistant. So the only available solution, for now, is to switch to ZIGBEE2MQTT or DECONZ. Also, Zigbee2mqtt apparently added support for new devices quickly while ZHA First Phoscon, then Zigbee2MQTT (Z2M) and most recently Zigbee Home Automation (ZHA): I have extensively tested all three ZigBee gateway software solutions with Home Assistant and am now using ZHA, which is also the primary topic of this article. Migrating from ZHA to zigbee2mqtt best practice? Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. "omerk" who designed the open-source zzh adapter) plus several longer Zigbee range discussions threads found all around in Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. The recommendations are largely indirectly based on posts in different communities with recommendations from experienced Zigbee developers (like Koen Kanters a. 1 Like. I’ve spent countless hours researching and tinkering with no results. Just copy the network and import in ZHA. Zigbee2mqtt. I have successfully setup an SMLight coordinator using poe ethernet. However, not all devices are supported by ZHA and it seems that Zigbee2Mqtt supports more (eg. That caused some head scratching till I figured it out! Config of ZHA just FYI, ITead just released a new “ZBDongle-E” adapter as an improved version of their old/previous barebone Silabs EFR32MG21 based Zigbee 3. 95% are main powered and 5 IKEA repeaters spread around the house. 0 dongle and would like to have a look at zigbee2mqtt, just to understand the difference etc. 2. Basic configuration is, press button on device and on Home assistant and entity shows up. The question I’m asking, what should I do with my zigbee network now that HUE is getting the matter update. Spent the best part of the 10 months trying to get a stable zigbee2MQTT up and running. However, here’s why you might want to do this: If I pair different devices in Zigbee2MQTT or ZHA while they Hi all I’m a complete noob, in fact I’ve not even started anything yet. And a zigbee2mqtt network with an CC2531 stick. ZHA certainly seems more flexible in what it will be able to offer (and for example, my Hue Dimmers can support After my first attempts with ZHA I recognized some issues like not showing battery status on some of my Aqara E1 Thermostats so that I decided to test Zigbee2MQTT. My goal: Migrate my Zigbee-Devices/Network from ZHA (Zigbee Home Assistant) integration to Z2M (Zigbee2MQTT). However, I only see one control: Switching it on and off. Silicon Labs Multiprotocol add-on (version 2. It feels like I should be able to find the answer easily but the more I look, the more confused I become. I had a semi-stable ZHA network with the Sky connect that linked to the Alexa app which meant I could use voice commands. Zigbee2MQTT offers those configuration capabilities. This will rename the device and entity_id inside I have a pi with IOTstack installed including HA, nodered, zigbee2mqtt and others. After many years of me helping many ZHA and Zigbee2MQTT end-users here in this community forum or other support channels for those two projects I can tell you from my own first-hand experience that while it is true that most users do tend to use stable wired Ethernet LAN connection and therefore those often seem to have no problems there are ZHA in Home Assistant does the job for most people, while Zigbee2MQTT is the king of supported devices. deCONZ vs ZHA vs zigbee2mqtt. Available for free at home-assistant. This video is A MUST SEE comparison between the three main As a basic principle of how I have things setup: Voice, Manual overrides wherever possible, It also means restarting Home Assistant, which unfortunately you still need to do to update certain things, will also make your Zigbee devices unavailable for some time. I literally watched hours on youtube on how to set up Zigbee2MQTT but there are just a minor numbers of dealing with SkyConnect. Note: event entity is experimental and may break in the future. But you may also want to consider Zigbee2MQTT as an alternative, and this blog post will explain the differences. Zigbee2mqtt has support for more devices, but ZHA has support for more I recently started a new smart home setup after moving into a new apartment. The Tuya Zigbee Fingerbot Plus can be integrated in Home Assistant through ZHA and Zigbee2MQTT. Zigbee2mqtt setup allows you to use your Zigbee devices without a vendor's gateway. 9. Thanks doe the headsup to enocean2mqtt, I maybe a better solution would be connecting a Zigbee USB adapter to Home Assistant and using ZHA or Zigbee2MQTT or Zigbee2Tasmota? Zigbee network depends heavily on its mesh networking technology so best is always to try to have all your Zigbee devices connected to the same Zigbee network, (and Zigbee devices can only be connected to a I could use some assistance with Zigbee groups & clusters (using ZHA and an EZSP). My Home Assistant is on the 192. Change in the Silcon Labs Mulitprotocol add-on the baud rate to 115200 instead of 460800. Today, we’re diving deep into two popular Zigbee integration options for Home Assistant: Zigbee2MQTT (Z2M) and Zigbee Home Automation (ZHA). 0 USB Dongle Plus V2” (model “ZBDongle-E”) , Aeotec Zi-Stick (model “ZGA008”), as well as in the easyiot ZB-GW04 The issue was missing configuration capabilities in ZHA. donnib October 19, 2020, You can create groups within deCONZ and call them from HA with a single API call. right now all i have is a ZOOZ zwave stick. Z2M Hi, Looking at the well known Database of Zigbee devices, I noticed that there are quite some devices that are supported by Zigbee2MQTT, but not by ZHA. Same issues here, using ZHA, getting those same, slightly odd event names. <details><summary>Original Post</summary>This blueprint is part of the Awesome HA Blueprints project. , don’t work Zigbee compliant device. My hardware: I’ve got a flashed Sonoff P-dongle and about 20 devices (temp-sensors, light switches, motion-sensors, some battery driven, some on the grid) Home Assistant’s own built-in ZHA integration and Zigbee2MQTT which are two most popular open-source and hardware-independent Zigbee Gateway implementationsfor Home Assistant integration will allow you do use almost any Zigbee device with Home Assistant, and with either one of those you will be able to mix devices from different manufacturers. ZHA uses an open-source Python library implementing a ZB-GW03 eWeLink Ethernet Zigbee Gateway is a spiritual successor of the ITead Sonoff ZBBridge It features an ESP32 chip and a wired Ethernet port (instead of the older ESP8266/ESP8285 and WiFi). I had been running Zigbee2MQTT with this setupfor a couple of years now with about a dozen sensors from Aqara and IKEA Tradfri lightbulbs. Ive found it to be unreliable with certain devices so I want to go back to zigbee2mqtt and see if thats any better. This is a bit harder to set up but in the long run is more robust. Understanding Zigbee2MQTT (Z2M) Zigbee2MQTT is an open-source project that enables Zigbee dev The official “Zigbee Home Automation” (ZHA) integration is the Zigbee gateway solution that is natively built into Home Assistant and is what is official supported by the Home Assistant founders + Nabu Casa (and really the Zigbee gateway solution that this specific forum is about other than Zigbee devices/hardware products that can possibly be used with this official Zigbee2mqtt Home Assistant VS ZHA Home Assistant. i. (Home Assistant 2023. yaml for Zigbee2MQTT or else devices in pairing/joining mode will automatically pair/join to the Zigbee2MQTT network i,e, it makes the Zigbee2MQTT Zigbee Gateway always remain in pairing/joining mode instead of for only a limited time when set, which actually goes Zigbee2MQTT and vice versa will only be able to restore the backup of the Zigbee level, not a backup at the application level. 0 dongle. I liked these two I’ve used both Zigbee2MQTT and ZHA, as well as a number of other zigbee network setups : Hue, Ikea, Tuya, Smartthings, Google, Amazon, Apple, my own hillbilly tech . It appears to be more reliable than the other options, but this is purely anecdotal. Would people recommend starting with ZHA or Zigbee2MQTT? I'm running HA in a Docker Container if that makes any difference. Both have some OTA support, z2m is probably better, but the latest zha toolkit can now use the z2m OTA repository, leveling the playing field, even if not fully GUI integrated. zigbee2mqtt uses MQTT which separates the Zigbee processing from Home Assistant. After installing HA I disabled the zigbee2mqtt and tried ZHA instead. There is no list for ZHA because it aims to support all compliant devices out of the box - a list would be impossible to compile. Until now I have only used WiFi based sensors. However, I’d like to avoid repairing all the devices. Looks like ZHA seems to be "most used?" with zigbee2mqtt coming in second? Or am I missing something? Shooting for WAF, and Hi, I know I have put my self in this stupid situation. Im going to start with simple automations, but I will want the most advanced features in the future as my knowledge of it grows. Read more about it on the related Community Forum topic. Follow this link for more info: [New device support]: Linptech Presence Sensor ES1 (TS0225__TZ3218_awarhusb) · Issue #18637 · Koenkk/zigbee2mqtt (github. But i’ve read a lot and can’t find a good solution. Home Assistant’s own built-in ZHA integration and Zigbee2MQTT which are two most popular open-source and hardware-independent Zigbee Gateway implementationsfor Home Assistant integration will allow you do use almost any Zigbee device with Home Assistant, and with either one of those you will be able to mix devices from different manufacturers. Hello - I would really appreciate any guidance on this issue. 1) Mosquitto broker add-on (version 6. I run a number of other systems in containers as well, the communicate with Home Assistant via API or I need a point in the right direction as I’m very confused. I hope you guys can help me choose which one to buy. The list both their Hello, at the moment I have some Zigbee devices connected via mqtt (zigbee2mqtt) in home assistant. I have the following installed: Matter Server add-on (version 5. 1-1 Zigbee on channel 11 and wifi 2. 0) MQTT Integration Mosquitto broker addon 6. This is a common problem and Zigbee2mqtt suggests to disable Hi all, ive been running zigbee2mqtt with a Sonoff Dongle-E flashed to the latest stable version known to work well with z2m and zha. “ZHA WebSocket”) which goal I understand was to break out the ZHA integration component into its own stand-alone websocket server application and re-implement ZHA in a fork that uses that socket interface instead, using a client-server model architecture: What's better for connecting Zigbee devices directly to Home Assistant - Zigbee2MQTT or ZHA (Zigbee Home Automation)? ️ Found this video useful and want to s So the Conbee stick works with both ZHA and deCONZ, HUSBZB-1 is for ZHA but includes Z-Wave, and for zigbee2mqtt I need a CC2531 and debugger, is that correct? Strawpoll. Aqara’s I’ve been starting with ZHA and I have realised that Zigbee2mqtt seems to have better device support for the current devices I’ve been buying like Aqara TVOC sensor and Aqara power plug. ADMIN MOD Conbee vs Sonoff and ZHA vs Zigbee2MQTT . Zigbee2MQTT . This vid There are two main Zigbee integrations - Zigbee Home Automation (ZHA) and Zigbee2MQTT (Z2M). This blueprint will allow you to control anything with an IKEA RODRET Dimmer (On/Off remote + dimming) or IKEA SOMRIG via ZHA or Zigbee2MQTT. 08. 4 on channel 6 My problem is that suddenly everything stops working. ⬇ Get ZHA is easier Zigbee2MQTT supports a wider range of devices, and supports new devices quicker Reply reply Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. ZHA operates using an So – ZHA vs Zigbee2MQTT – which system should you use? As I said it depends. Since I have 57 devices, it’s nice to do What's better for connecting Zigbee devices directly to Home Assistant - Zigbee2MQTT or ZHA (Zigbee Home Automation)? ️ Found this video useful and want to s I’m using the ZHA integration and some Rodret blueprints - the issue seems to be that the switches are recognised and added to HA but nothing happens when a switch is pressed. It does include a network map and Home Assistant as a general Hello everyone, I currently have Zigbee2mqtt set up for all my Zigbee devices. I’m familiar that Zigbee2MQTT has more device compatibility and features for automating, but This has been asked before, but a long time ago, however I want to revisit it with a new angle I understand that Z2M and ZHA can be run on the same machine, so long as you have 2 coordinators and those coordinators only do one or the other My extension of the question is, a) can the coordinators be the same device (e. 0 USB adapter from ITead and this new variant is to be sold side-by I’m integrating zigbee using zigbee2mqtt. Before this, it was Seems to be working fine so far unlike ZHA which kept going into an endless loop. boldie December 28, 2023, 3:52pm 63. I’ve noticed many times in forum posts, and by looking at ZHA developer dmulcahey begun work on a side-project called “ZHA WS” (e. Converting to Zigbee2MQTT Converting between ZHA (built-in Zigbee Home Assistant) and Zigbee2MQTT is a lot more involved, and neither solution is going to 100% solve every issue. Home Assistant Community deCONZ vs ZHA vs zigbee2mqtt. k. two Sonoff USB dongles) b) are there any Today I tried out ZHA (been using deCONZ) to see if I could get my ecosmart remotes to pair (I haven’t been able to pair them with Home Assistant using a Conbee II and deCONZ). Nordic I’m using ZHA for my Zigbee netwoork but notice that using Zigbee2MQTT may provide additional functionality for some of my devices as well as open up the possibility to use devices not available through ZHA (yet). I wired the bulbs to always be on, and the switch has no load connected. 2 Operating System 10. io) xman111 (Craig) February 10, 2021, 4:45pm 40. 5 Frontend 20230911. If using Zigbee2MQTT see Improved Ember (EZSP) driver (experimental) · Koenkk/zigbee2mqtt · Discussion #21462 · FYI, SMLIGHT released SMLIGHT SLZB-07 Zigbee Coordinator USB radio adapter based on the same popular Silicon Labs EFR32MG21 radio SoC/MCU that is also used in the Home Assistant SkyConnect (USB stick), ITead’s “Sonoff Zigbee 3. Zigbee2MQTT - Meine Endgültige Empfehlung! Zigbee - Home Assistant Community kurz überflogen und zumindest der Beginn sieht für diese Richtung nicht positiv aus My Zigbee devices are a bit of a mess. yyfl zdgd mozp hwnhcic svevpayy maxrhav nyh hjtr dgnsrkc zstu